From: Rob Brumbaugh []
Sent: Friday, October 10, 2008 7:02 AM
To: Robert Brumbaugh
Subject: Shellfish Clamor October 2008


Shellfish Restoration Network
Native shellfish play vital ecological roles in many estuaries, but are imperiled in many estuaries by habitat loss, over fishing, and pollution. Through a Shellfish Restoration Network, The Nature Conservancy and its partners are working to improve the design and implementation of restoration projects that help to illustrate the ecosystem services that shellfish provide. Through this network, we also hope to demonstrate the elements necessary to expand restoration and conservation to ecosystem scales.

Global Marine Initiative's Vision
"The Nature Conservancy and partners working together in polar, temperate and tropical seas worldwide to conserve marine biodiversity effectively across seascapes and landscapes through transformative strategies and integrated planning and action."

To Join the Network, contact:
Rob Brumbaugh
Restoration Program Director
The Nature Conservancy, Global Marine Initiative or

For more information about The Nature Conservancy’s
Global Marine Initiative, visit:

October 2008
Distributed by The Nature Conservancy's Global Marine Initiative

First Contact: A motley team of researchers encounters the Native oysters of Nootka Island and learns a thing or two   By Rowan Jacobson 

           A multi-disciplinary team surveyed remote sections of British Columbia's coastline in July to document the existence of Olympia oyster beds.  Credit:  Rowan Jacobson

In the early 1990s, a Canadian marine scientist named Brian Kingzett was engaged in an ecologist’s dream job. The province of British Columbia wanted to know how much of its remote and convoluted coastline had the potential for shellfish aquaculture, and it hired Kingzett to find out. Kingzett was following a long line of explorers, including James Cook and George Vancouver, commissioned to mess about in boats along one of the wildest and most breathtaking coasts in North America. He surveyed the shore from Victoria all the way to the border with Alaska, recording the locations and characteristics of the beaches, surveying the species present, and snapping photographs of the most promising spots. Camping in the bush for days at a time, he came to know the coast like few others and saw some amazing things. One night he navigated by the luminescent seas as waves broke against reefs. He watched sea otters leave glowing trails like shooting stars as they dove. On a different trip, he anchored near remote hot springs every night.

One thing Kingzett saw stuck with him. He had pulled into a long inlet near Nootka Island at low tide and, pressed for time, was surveying the pocket beaches as quickly as possible. Most of the inlet was sheer rock plunging to depths of a hundred feet just a few yards offshore, but wherever a stream flowed out of the mountains, a cobbly delta had built up over the millennia, forming beautiful shellfish habitat. Kingzett would nose his boat onto each beach, leap ashore, jot down his notes, snap a photo, and zip on to the next. As soon as he set foot on the first beach in this particular inlet (name withheld to protect the innocent), he noticed something unusual. There were a smattering of mussels and Pacific oysters, plenty of barnacles and clams underneath, but portions of the beach were absolutely littered with small, round oysters—Natives. Native oysters (known as Olympias or ‘Olys’ in the U.S.) weren’t one of Kingzett’s specialties and he wasn’t familiar with their status elsewhere on the Pacific coast, but it was unusual enough to see them in such abundance that he made a mental note of it. In his seven years of surveying the coasts, he found just a handful of beaches burgeoning with Natives.

Fast forward ten years. Kingzett was at a shellfish conference and met Betsy Peabody. He asked her what she did. She told him about her Oly restoration efforts with Puget Sound Restoration Fund (PSRF). He said, “That’s funny, ten years ago I came across acres of those little guys.” As you can imagine, Betsy was just a wee bit interested.

In July 2008, I accompanied a multidisciplinary team, guided by Kingzett himself, into the fjords of Vancouver Island, not far from Nootka Island. Our goal was to find these oly populations, if they still existed, and to learn what we could from them—to use these natural beds, which may have been around for millennia, as a kind of role model for the habitat enhancement efforts PSRF is leading in Puget Sound. Team members such as Joth Davis, lead scientist on PSRF’s native oyster enhancement projects; Brian Allen, PSRF staff ecologist; Mike Beck, Senior Scientist for The Nature Conservancy’s Global Marine Team; Sarah Davies, a biologist with Canada’s Department of Fisheries and Oceans; Stephanie Richards, master provisioner and Captain with the Centre for Shellfish Research at Vancouver Island; and David Hyde, a producer with an NPR affiliate station in Seattle (KUOW), helped put the “multi” in multidisciplinary. Betsy Peabody supplied the team’s discipline.

Imagine that somebody in the future stumbled upon one of the last cars in existence. It was a Ferrari, scattered in pieces, and wasn’t functioning, but a lot of the pieces seemed to be in pretty good shape. This future dweller wanted to put the thing back together, but he’d never seen a working car and didn’t even have a manual. How would he go about doing it? Well, he’d start tinkering, using his common sense, and if he was really handy, maybe he’d get it running and firing on a couple of cylinders. He’d roll across the land at five miles an hour and consider it a success, having no idea that there were missing pieces he’d never seen, and that a car is capable of much, much more.

That’s the situation facing those working to restore the Puget Sound ecosystem. The system still works, but decades of poor maintenance and occasional breakdowns have left it limping along. Few people can even remember that it used to run differently. But it is capable of doing much more for us.

If you wanted to restore a vintage Ferrari and you couldn’t find a manual, the first thing you’d do is to take a look at another Ferrari of the same model. When Brian Kingzett met Betsy Peabody, what he was basically telling her was, “Hey, when I was poking around those fjords, I came across a 308 GT in excellent condition.” So we went to check it out.

The ecosystem of Vancouver Island’s west coast is still firing on all cylinders. Its intertidal zone is a biological hotspot teeming with mussels, barnacles, oysters, clams, rock scallops, periwinkles, limpets, crabs, sea stars, sculpins, and seaweeds of all kinds. Black bears camp out on the beaches, rolling rocks to get at the gunnels beneath. Eagles loiter in the spruce tops and black crows scoop up clams and shatter them on the rocks. Offshore, the kelp beds are thick with rockfish and urchins. Gangs of sea otters cruise the lanes, hustling up pounds of clams, urchins, and crabs every day. They even excavate geoducks, leaving bomb craters in the sand.

One of the lynchpins holding all this together is the oyster beds. Like little rivets bolting the sea to the land, they are what makes the ecosystem one seamless whole. But would they still be there? As we boated for hours through the fjords aboard the MV Atrevida, a research vessel whose name means audacious and whose namesake was one of the ships Captain Alexandro Malaspina used to explore these very inlets in 1791, Kingzett worried about the oysters. It had been fourteen years, after all, since he’d last seen them.

On our first full day, we arrived too late to catch the low tide, so Kingzett steered the inflatable near one of the pocket beaches and we dangled our heads over the side, noses pressed against the glassy surface. Nothing but clams, mussels, barnacles, more clams. Then, suddenly, the surface dropped a foot and there they were: oysters everywhere. The mother beds had survived. Soon, Joth Davis and Brian Allen were in the water, snorkeling with their favorite bivalve.

The expedition brought together journalists, scientists, managers and conservationists to describe some the best remaining Olympia oyster beds in the world.  Credit: Joth Davis

The next morning, we yanked ourselves awake early enough to catch the 7 a.m. low tide, concentrating our efforts at the head of the inlet, where an oyster bed several acres wide spread in glorious profusion. We set to work taking an oyster census, keeping a watchful eye on the bears foraging a bit higher on the beach. We counted oysters, measured beds, and asked some questions. What were they setting on? Who was living with them? What were they eating? Who was eating them? Did they prefer intertidal or subtidal living? We wanted to know why these oysters had persisted here for so long and whether the same conditions might benefit Puget Sound’s olys.

Mike Beck, Senior Scientist with The Nature Conservancy's Global Marine Team, collects data on Olympia oysters density in a remote pocket beach.  Credit: Brian Kingzett

A few important things we learned or observed:

  • Unlike Pacific oysters, Native oysters are not reef builders, per se. Rather, in the Port Eliza area, they form flat beds, little more than one oyster deep, on rocky substrate, with a rich layer of clams underneath.
  • Rock seems to be the preferred substrate in this location, followed closely by native oysters and native oyster shell.
  • The pocket beaches associated with drainages in this otherwise steep glaciated fjord seem to have no shortage of setting substrate (rock in this case), as compared to places like Puget Sound where setting substrate can sometimes be the limiting factor.
  • Perhaps most important, we learned that Native oysters and humans can live well together. This was no pristine inlet. Logging was heavy on the upland slopes and had been for decades. According to Vancouver Island’s West Coast, a history of the area written by George Nicholson in 1962, “Acres of native oyster beds occur at the head of the inlet, from which thousands of sacks were once shipped to Vancouver and Seattle…. Now they are free to anyone who wishes to gather them.” Within certain limits, Olys don’t need to be coddled or walled off to thrive. They have been and can continue to be an important source of food and habitat for a variety of creatures in the area, including Homo sapiens.

In addition to its array of quadrats, calipers, shellstrings, hobos temperature sensors, fyke-net traps, plankton pumps, and algae presses, our team used its sophisticated sensory apparatus to analyze several Olys for qualities such as salinity, amino acid content, and yumminess. The samples proved to be high in all three categories. Thus encouraged, we performed the same analysis on a number of other species in the area. We dug clams. We shucked pacific oysters. We caught sole. We ate beach onion and pickleweed. Let it be noted that the high tides gave us some down time.

When it came to procuring seafood, the only animal in the vicinity that could give the sea otters a run for their money was team member Brian Allen. With wetsuit and speargun, Allen plunged into the kelp beds offshore and emerged with a string of rockfish. He cut a six-foot strand of kelp so that I could make miso soup with the fronds and Betsy Peabody could make pickles with the stalk. He popped limpets off their rocky purchases and grilled them in their inverted shells for the ultimate beach appetizer.

All this foraging gave us a profound sense of the abundance of the area, which is perhaps the defining characteristic of the Pacific Northwest coast. We love the Pacific Northwest for its drama and its stark, misty beauty, but we especially love it because for ten thousand years it has been a really, really good place for people to live. Evidence of that was all around us on Nootka Island. At Friendly Cove, we spoke with the descendents of the Nuu-chah-nulth tribe that welcomed Captain James Cook to these shores in 1778. From our base in the Nuchatlitz Islands, we could look down a sinuous tidal canal and see a line of boulders placed as a fish trap by that same tribe centuries ago. And on one particularly stunning pocket beach of oysters, I worked around a mysterious semicircle of rock for hours before Brian Kingzett pointed out that this, too, had been a fish trap. Fish came in on the high tide, then got trapped as the receding waters trickled out between the rocks. All you had to do was scoop up the stragglers. Easy livin’.

That pocket beach proved to be the prize find of the trip. We didn’t discover it until our last day, when we fanned out to survey new spots. Mike Beck and I had been dropped off to check this particular beach, and it took us all of about three seconds to see that this one was special. The red, green, and black cobble was gilded with a nearly continuous sheen of white-gold oysters. We excitedly snapped photos and tossed quadrats. Densities in some spots exceeded 600 oysters per square meter—a concentration unheard of in Puget Sound—and gave a hint of how beautiful and productive a Native oyster bed can be. “Look at this,” Mike said. “These oysters are the dominant life form on this beach. They are the structure.” If all you’ve ever seen of olys are the patchy survivors in Puget Sound, and you’ve wondered how such critters could have fueled a vast industry from San Francisco to Vancouver for decades, one look at this bed would make it all clear. We had only the briefest of chances to learn about this Ferrari of an oyster bed that goes by the humble name of Pocket Beach #3, so a return trip is vital for future restoration efforts, not to mention our newly attuned culinary appreciation for the rich assortment of coastal offerings.

As the Atrevida pulled away from shore, Mike Beck posed a question to us—one that has yet to be answered. “From a conservation perspective,” he asked, “what would you do about something like this? It probably isn’t the only beach like this on Vancouver Island, but say there’s three or four, and maybe another twenty like the one at the head of the inlet. And that’s it. In the whole world. What would you do to make sure this ecosystem doesn’t vanish?”

Data from Olympia oyster beds found along Vancouver's remote coastline may help to guide future restoration efforts in Puget Sound.  Credit: Brian Kingzett

Rowan Jacobsen is the author of A Geography of Oysters, a 2008 James Beard Award winner, and Fruitless Fall: The Collapse of the Honey Bee and the Coming Agricultural Crisis

Back to top »

Looking Ahead

11th International Conference on Shellfish Restoration (ICSR)
November 19-22, 2008, Charleston, South Carolina
ABSTRACT DEADLINE – August 1, 2008

 101st Annual Meeting of the National Shellfisheries Association
March 22-26, 2009, Savannah, Georgia
Abstracts accepted through November 18, 2008

International Marine Conservation Congress – Making Marine Science Matter
May 20-24, 2009, Washington DC
First call for oral presentations: Abstracts DUE by October 15, 2008

Back to top »

Web Resources

The Practitioner’s Guide to Shellfish Restoration: An Ecosystem Services Approach, as well as back issues of the Shellfish Restoration Clamor are available online.

Guidance on methods for monitoring oyster reef restoration projects is available at the Oyster Restoration Workgroup website.

Cool Video!  A constituent of shellfish restoration appears in the video clip provided by Chesapeake Bay Gateways Network.

Back to top »



If you no longer wish to receive these emails, please reply to this message with "Unsubscribe" in the subject line or simply click on the following link: Unsubscribe

The Nature Conservancy
Global Marine Intiative
215 South Ferry Road
URI Bay Campus
Narragansett, RI 02882

Read the VerticalResponse marketing policy.

Try Email Marketing with VerticalResponse!